Monday, November 28, 2016

Establishing a Positive Classroom Climate in the Art Room


Aside from creating beautiful artwork that my students can be proud of, creating a positive climate in my art room is my top prerogative. It is a multi-step process with layers of interwoven elements, not unlike a mixed-media piece of work, where each element builds on the next – incorporating, juxtaposing, balancing and emphasizing the next – to create a cohesive, pleasing work of art. And like the process of making great art, one’s work is never complete. Art is simply considered ‘complete’ when nothing about it bothers you any longer -- when you just can’t think of anything else to add or change. When the classroom dynamic reaches this point of satisfaction, then you know you and your students have done well. And the cycle continues with the start of the next project…

 Ms. Britt’s Art Room is a cozy, creative nest of young people from many different backgrounds and language groups. Our common verbal language is English, which we speak at various stages of proficiency, and our visual language is art, in which we are learning to express ourselves weekly. With smudgy fingers and paint-stained aprons we wield our tools with both mathematical precision and subconscious-directed free movements. Our work is guided by me and created by the students, but our results are achieved by us all…..because our work is directly affected by the classroom climate, and because are all responsible for this climate.

The first measure of importance for establishing a positive classroom is getting to know your students. Knowing a student, or anyone for that matter, requires far more than merely learning their names (and pronouncing them correctly), but also knowing their age (and remembering their birthdays), knowing where they come from (country and/or community) and understanding their cultural and linguistic heritage. Getting to know their parents is an integral element of knowing students too, as families can be a powerful alliance and a bridge between myself and the student – after all, teachers and parents have similar goals, hopes and concerns for the child, so working together on this common ground can be quite effective.


Once the student is ‘known’ to the teacher, is it the teacher’s role to ensure that the students are meaningfully engaged and involved in their learning. This means drawing on their experiences and their personal narratives to enrich the curriculum. Materials, texts, famous persons bios and projects must be chosen which reflect the classroom demographics and interests.

In the Art Room I engage an open-ended, student-centered, collaborative model of curriculum design. On display on the walls around us are many examples of art projects, artists and artwork, which the students look at and become absorbed in. Often, they are so smitten with the art on display that they beg me to let them do the art project. This scenario actively engages them and allows them to choose and direct their own learning, which always results in higher learning outcomes.

Ideas from my art projects are very often influenced directly my students’ experiences, environment or interests. This can mean designing a project which is seasonal, for example, it’s snowing outside – let’s do a snowy pop-art landscape painting: or, it’s Thanksgiving – let’s do a line drawing of a turkey focusing on rendering texture and blending with oil pastels. It can also mean celebrating cultural heritage through art. For example, instead of the run-of-the-mill jack-o-lantern project around Halloween, why not do a Dia de los Muertos ‘sugar skull’ project which is celebrated in Mexico at the same time as Halloween, and has similar pagan tenets, but it expands classroom cultural literacy, inter-culture dialogue while also teaching about geography, language and the value of multiple perspectives. How exciting is that!

The choices I make in the curriculum have a direct impact on the inter-personal and inter-social relations in the classroom, and when done right, can make students feel valued, engaged and excited about learning. They will feel ready and motivated to learn. However, curricular choices do not alone lead to safe, nourishing classroom environments. It is also critically important to be mindful of the types and characteristics of communication practices in the classroom. In order to learn, student must feel safe. Therefore, communications between teachers and students, and between students, must be carefully chosen and monitored. Any incidences of harassment or bullying must be promptly addressed. Likewise, racist comments and insensitive remarks (even when unintentional) but be addressed in an open, non-accusatory format which allows for understating and dialogue.

Words carry serious weight and they must not be thrown around haphazardly. One incident in my the Art Room which reminds me of how painful words can be goes back a few weeks during a portrait painting and color-mixing lesson I was doing with my youngest students, aged 5-7 years old. We were learning how to mix our own paints to create skin tones. One little girl ended up with a very dark brown color, despite attempting to achieve a lighter pale pink hue in her own likeness. Upset with her results, she blurted out “ugh, I hate brown skin!” The little south Indian boy sitting next to her lifted his head suddenly when he heard this remark, and his sad, startled eyes said it all: words (even if unintentional) can hurt deeply. This situation became an opportunity for all of us to talk about the wide spectrum of skin colors, where we all come from, and the value of looking beyond skin color. It also informed our art making process, as it made us realize that just as the results for mixing skin colors on our palette seemed to be infinite, so is the represetation of skin colors in people in our community.

In the Art Room, making art is so much more than the beautiful chef d’ouevre the students bring home each week. They are learning the skills of being informed and open-minded citizens, compassionate and consciensous peers and friends, and mindful, careful communicators. I know we are on the right track when this learning happens seamlessly and effectively within and beyond the curriculum, and continues to generate a positive climate outside the walls of the Art Room.

Source: Critical Practices for Anti-bias Education. http://www.tolerance.org/sites/default/files/general/PDA%20Critical%20Practices_0.pdf


SaveSave

Monday, November 21, 2016

Planning an Art Lesson with English Language Learners in Mind


 Orcas in their Habitat

The objective of this project is to introduce the concept of atmospheric perspective and build on prior knowledge of shadowing, highlighting, blending, using acrylics and line drawing. This lesson was planned with the differing needs of four English language learners in mind, each at a different stage in their language learning development. 

Liv is an 8-year old German girl in the Pre-Production stage of learning English. She attends a German school, and has little to no English exposure outside of my weekly art class. She is in the “silent period”, taking in language largely from visual and gestural cues, and by observing her peers. She listens and watches for cues attentively, and indicates with eye contact when she needs clarity.

Phoebe is an 8-year old girl from China in the Speech Emergent stage. She speaks eagerly and enthusiastically in short, simple sentences, though her speech is difficult to understand, heavily accented, and with many grammatical and syntactical errors. She understands simple instructions accompanied by visuals, gestural cues and demonstrations. She is a resourceful student who observes her peers to check her own understanding, and does not hesitate to ask for help.

Koh is a 7-year old boy from Japan in the Intermediate Fluency stage. He speaks and shares ideas with relative fluency, but makes minor grammatical and sentence structure mistakes. He processes new concepts well but often needs guidance on synthesizing his learning.

Vita is a 10-year old girl from Croatia in the Advanced Fluency stage. Vita speaks with ease, yet demonstrates occasional gaps in academic vocabulary. Complex concepts are quickly grasped and processed, and she is comfortable analyzing and explaining these concepts.

1. The first part of this two-session lesson is dedicated to drawing an orca whale from observation and painting it using acrylic paints. 

a.  Prior knowledge of key art elements and vocabulary are assessed. Students are given a variety of orca whale pictures to analyze and are asked to discuss in pairs the orca’s qualities (line, shape, color, features).  Liv is seated next to and paired with a German-speaking “buddy” who reiterates instructions for her and models the exercise. Liv listens and repeats. The pairs share their findings. Phoebe is asked to present a few findings. Her mistakes are not corrected, instead, I repeat the sentence or word correctly. Koh is asked to expound on one feature (he says the orca is jumping out of the ocean: I ask him to describe the texture of the water). Vita is asked to expound in detail on her observations. 

b.   We discuss shadows and highlights. Students point these out on the orca. Students are directed to the word wall where they can see these terms defined with clear visuals.

c.  We begin our line drawing. I model a line drawing on the white board emphasizing and highlighting various features (placement of the fin, curve of the back) with the aid of different colored markers and arrows.

d.   Painting phase. The teacher example is on display. Features, highlights and shadows are pointed out, spoken clearly and written on the board. Students paint their orca, adding highlights and shadows.

2.  The second session involves painting the orca’s habitat. In this session students are introduced to the concept of “atmospheric perspective”. We learn new brush techniques and build on prior knowledge of blending and watercolor techniques.

a.    Students are shown a slide show of orcas in their habitat. They discuss in groups and write words or symbols that come to mind which describe their habitat (ocean, cold, Arctic, Antarctica, they eat seals). Words are written on the board together with symbols and gestures (cold: snowflake and shiver gesture) as students present them. Liv is encouraged to present word suggestions using gesturing.

b.    “Atmospheric perspective” is defined. It is written on the board and the class says it aloud several times. Students are asked to observe from pictures and by looking out the window how the appearance of objects changes when viewed from a distance. Vita and Koh are asked to provide descriptions. Phoebe is asked to point out and name the colors she identifies in the ocean (dark blue, blue, light blue etc.). These words are written on the board and repeated aloud, with connectors drawn to the matching color in the picture, which helps Liv make the connection. In groups students are asked to reflect on where they have personally observed examples of atmospheric perspective: the seaside, from atop a mountain etc. Koh and Vita are asked to expound to the class.

c.   Painting and collaging phase. A teacher example is displayed of what is expected of the final result. Painting takes place in a step-by-step, teacher-led format, using short, simple directions with demonstrations. Several options for possibilities for variations are modeled on the board. Brush techniques (for rendering texture) are modeled with clear explanations. Rendering atmospheric perspective, shadows and highlights are discussed and demonstrated as we paint. Eye contact is regularly made with students to check that techniques have been grasped and progress is being made. At this point, students are given individual reminders and pointers of key concepts and techniques where needed. 

d.   When painting is complete, our orcas are cut out and collaged onto their habitat and splashes are added using a new brush technique, which is clearly and succinctly explained and demonstrated.

3.  Finally, five minutes are spent in an art critique. Students are asked to provide constructive criticism (what did he do well, what can she do better next time, etc.). Vita and Koh are encouraged to back up their opinions with deeper explanations. Phoebe is asked to share her opinions using short, simple phrases, while Liv is encouraged to point to areas and use gestures to communicate her opinions. All students are proud of their work and  have once again learned that hard work pays off! 


Sources:
Everything ESL.net. Stages of Second Language Acquisition. http://www.everythingesl.net/inservices/language_stages.php
Colorin Colorado. Language Acquisition. An Overview. http://www.colorincolorado.org/article/language-acquisition-overview

Saturday, November 12, 2016

A Look Inside Bonn International School's Special Education Referral Process 


Special education is instruction which is specially designed to meet the unique learning needs of children with a disability. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) is in place to ensure that all children with a disability receive a free, quality education in the least restrictive environment whenever possible. In order to qualify to special education, children must be identified as having one of the 14 special education categories, and their learning in regular classrooms must be hindered by this disability.

Today, children with disabilities are educated together with non-disabled children in regular classrooms. Teachers, staff and learning support specialist must therefore closely work together to identify and support these students within the regular curriculum and classroom setting. This requires making referrals to the special education team, followed by the development of a student’s Individual Educational Plan (IEP), if accepted for referral, and the continued collaboration and communication between teachers, specialists and parents.

To get a better picture of the special education referral process, and how it’s rolled out in practice, I spoke with two second grade teachers, the upper school art teacher, and a learning support specialist at the Bonn International School (BIS). I found that all teachers interviewed provided clear, thorough answers and a comprehensive overview of the process at the school. This gave me confidence that there is strong communication between teachers and specialists regarding students and their learning needs, and that school policy is clearly outlined and understood by all. Furthermore, from the detailed answers provided, I got the impression that the teachers are highly committed to ensuring the quality education of their students and that there is generous motivation, time and resources to support teachers in this task. I read this as a strong indication of the support and guidance teachers enjoy from school leadership in addressing the issue of special education and overall student success.


Questions put to the learning support specialist:
Q: What is the school administration's directive for special education?
Bonn International School does not use the term special education. Instead, they use 'learning support', or 'supported learning'. BIS endeavors to meet every student’s academic, emotional, social, and physical needs, however due to staffing, learning support services are restricted to students with mild learning difficulties. Early intervention consultation support is provided for students in the Early Years. The Learning Support specialist teachers provided assistance both in and out of the classroom in small groups.

Q: What is school policy is on serious mental and physical disabilities
The school is currently unable to meet the needs of more seriously disabled students. Families lack the breadth of options that they may have in the US. If a student requires assistance that is beyond the capacity of the learning support team, parents may be asked to provide and finance outside learning support help.

Q: What provisions are made for students identified for special education?
When a student is referred to and accepted into the learning support program, a learning support team is created consisting of the general ed teacher(s), the parents, the administration, and learning support teacher.  It is then the job of the team to ensure that the needs of that student are met. Referrals are very much seen as a collaborative and team building process.

Q: What is the level of parent involvement in the referral process and special education? And what if parents don't agree with the decision?
Since decisions about student learning are data-driven with the identification of measurable goals, decisions and learning plans are typically well-received by parents. The job of the learning specialist is to prove that the student is making adequate progress in their IEP. The use of data and strong communication generally prevents discord between school and parents.

Q: What happens when parents choose not to have their child labeled. Does an unlabeled diagnosis enjoy the same benefits/interventions as a labeled one?
Parents are helped to understand that labels are in place in order to better support their children’s success in school.


Questions put to classroom teachers:
Q: How do you identify a student for special education?
All three teachers were unanimous in their response that observation is the first line of attack in identifying a student for special education. This includes simple comparisons against ‘normal’ age-appropriate behavior and grade-level academic skills.

Q: What are the signs of a struggling student?
All teachers agreed on the telltale signs of a struggling student. These included difficultly with focus, concentration, organization and communication; difficulty recalling information; difficulty staying on task with inability to start and complete a project without assistance.

Q: Are there alternate methods of instruction tried out before referring the student for special education? If yes, what are they?
All teachers responded similarly to this question. They approach all students as individual learners with unique learning needs, and therefore, many of the methods used for teaching at the school are used for all students. Basic methods which ensure all students succeed are clear communications, instructions, demonstrations and written explanations. Positive reinforcement, routines, regular breaks for movement and fresh air were identified as positive classroom organization beneficial to all. More focused methods of instruction may include simplified texts, silencing headphones, math manipulative, partnerships, differentiated reading books, writing tasks and expectations, reducing learning into small more manageable portions, and the use of visuals and checklists.


I was impressed with what I learned from my interviews. From the teachers’ responses to my questions, it was clear that they each strive for student success and student confidence, and that wherever possible, teachers will research ways to make learning personalized and interesting. Motivation is high and commitments to students are strong. All students are seen as unique learners and each child receives personalized learning.  For those who have an IEP, strong and effective, data-driven support services are in place to ensure their academic success. Teachers work closely together with one another, the learning support team, parents and the administration to make this happen. The resources, the time, the collaboration and the institutional support are all in place to allow for the highest level of student engagement and support.

The way in which general and special education are taught and supported at this school reminds me of Finland’s approach to the normalization of special education (click to learn more) and to the personalized learning that takes place at New York’s School of One (click to learn more). When there is strong commitment to evaluating, understanding and collaborating on the learning needs, interests and styles of each student, then each student can succeed. When the curriculum is flexible, innovative and presented in a variety of different ways, then students can find the learning path that is most interesting and meaningful to them. The role of all education, whether regular or special, should strive to these ends. To hark Arthur C. Clark: when children have interest, education happens.



Sources:
Understanding the 13 Categories of Special Education: http://www.understandingspecialeducation.com/13-categories-of-special-education.html
A Parent Guide to 
Special Education, the IEP Process and School Successhttp://www.understandingspecialeducation.com
The Special Education Referral Process: http://www.projectidealonline.org/special-education-referral-process.php
The First Step: Determining Eligibility for Services: http://www.specialeducationguide.com/pre-k-12/individualized-education-programs-iep/the-iep-process-explained/
Finland's Formula for Education Success: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HsdFi8zMrYI
New Yorks School of One: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSTrI6nj5xU
Arthur C. Clarke quote in Sugata Mitra video: http://www.ted.com/talks/sugata_mitra_the_child_driven_education